Mafia - Brethren of the Coast (Pirate-themed) - DAY 5

[Cori]

Ayup. That's usually the second thing people do on the first voting day of a mafia game.

[Rinoko]

I don't like it. What happens when one of the Traitors or the Mutineer is chosen to roll(since there's a 50% chance of that) and they "just happen" to roll someone not on their side?

[Sarducar]

Well, being that Kerg is neither, he would be the obvious choice.

[Supaaku]

Agreed. Also what if the person rolling is actually a good honest pirate and they roll wrong? Would the ship lynch them the following day? If that happens then we lose. We'll be down to one person by tomorrow night while the Traitors and the Mutineers would have three each. This is of course assuming that the Traitor's kill another honest pirate during the night.

I don't think Kergan can actually get involved in the game to that degree. I might be wrong but I think it's always down to us to choose a lynch.

[The Nightman]

I don't think kerg would be allowed to do it since he's technically not in the game. It would have to be one of us.


If you guys trust me about what I said about being blocked last night, then I don't mind being the person to roll the random name.

[Supaaku]

Thing is though, no one can really be trusted. For example everything someone says could be a lie. What if the Seductress didn't actually visit anyone and you're just claiming they did. Call it paranoia, but I don't trust anyone.

[Supaaku]

And just to be on the safe side, DO NOT post a screenshot of the PM from Kergan if you have one. It'll likely just get you insta-killed

[The Nightman]

I don't blame you. Wouldn't posting a pm be considered meta gaming?

Hey mafia guys, one of you should out yourselves.

[Rinoko]

I don't blame you. Wouldn't posting a pm be considered meta gaming?

Yes, it is. Barabba found that out the hard way in Cori's mafia game.

Also, I'm sorry, but no lynch until we come up with a better plan than stabbing in the dark.

[The Nightman]

Hmm, a no lynch is probably the smartest choice, but I really don't want to waste this day. I'm still undecided for now.

[Rinoko]

New plan:



"Right! Everyone, close your eyes! Traitors, please raise your hand!"

[Sarducar]

Someone in the crew likes stabs in the dark.

[The Nightman]

We've been over this already Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch. Half of us pirates don't even have hands.

[Rinoko]

THEY'RE THE MOST SUSPICIOUS HALF

[Sarducar]

My role would be awkward without hands.