Mafia Gear Solid - Anti-Terrorist Unit Wins!!!

[The Nightman]

Well, I think that if we're going with a random lynch, I'll vote against Kitsune Dzelda just for the fact that he/she/it has at least a weak "lead" on her/him. Also, I don't think an innocent person would write a wall of text to defend themselves...kinda makes me think he/she is trying hard to hide something.

I vote lynch Kitsune Dzelda.

[Alec]

At this point, I'm inclined to take any hint, no matter how weak, as a potential lead.
And, what she has to gain, is that you might, in fact, be scum. Unless, of course, she is herself scum, but she's done nothing to suggest that at this point.

And, honestly, you are our only lead.

But yes. At this point, I will place my vote for Kitsune Dzelda.

[Lotharu]

That sounds reasonable, but I am gonna wait a bit longer to decide if I am actually gonna lynch her.
One more chance to defend.

[Kamak]

I'm not sure even this is a solid lead, so I'm going to sit this one out for now.

The two of you kinda seem suspect right now for jumping, but who knows, she might end up being scum that fucked up and got caught.

[Supaaku]

Banter, I'll make an exception for the edit thing this time because you are new and it may not have been clear that double posting is okay in mafia threads.

[FlyingGiraffe]

It's funny, before Dzelda put up that last post I was about to make the same argument that Banter's suspicions toward Dzelda were odd and perhaps lynch-worthy.

However, seeing you, Dzelda point that out makes me really suspicious of you as well. I get that you're trying to go for a "loose cannon" kind of deal, but it feels like you're trying too hard to keep up that attribute. It doesn't feel like you're naturally the part, and the fact that you continuously tell us you're a loose cannon instead of letting the introduction and your actions speak for you is curious. And outwardly attacking Banter like that (not even about the lynch, you directly tell him or her that "New people to this game tend to die quickly as well") is very suspicious as well.

I'd want to hear both of your explanations for your last few posts before I personally make any sort of decision though.

Also as a side note I wrote most of this before seeing that Granny Benson and Alec make similar points, but I'm keeping it as is since it's still kinda relevant.

[Alec]

Eh, at this point, I don't really care about voting suspiciously. It's enough evidence in my opinion for a day two lynch, and, as long as I keep tabs on this thread, I can change my vote as needed. But everything I thought is just getting backed up by others, so I don't think that will be the case.

[banter]

I never outright voted to lynch Dzelda because I recognized that my suspicions honestly weren't much; I was waiting to see if someone more observant than I would have better reasons to suspect someone else. As I noted in my last post, I'd been backing down a little because although Dzelda's suggestion to suspect whoever started the "no lynch" train did still strike me as a bit baseless, it doesn't necessarily make a solid enough reason for a lynching.

However, Dzelda's outright attack on me does make me more suspicious of their motives now. The fact that they tried to accuse my backing down and suggesting a possible random lynch (because I didn't want to go "no lynch" and I didn't really feel I had a good enough reason to lynch Dzelda themself so soon) as being a reason I was mafia is a bit silly. I was hardly the only one to bring up random lynching, anyway.

In addition, I have to agree that the "loose cannon" persona seems a bit affected. Honestly, that bothers me more than the attack on me. It doesn't really give me any reason to believe you're mafia, Dzelda, but it does bother me a little.

Still, I, like a few other people, think I'm going to wait for Dzelda to make some kind of defense post, because this could just be some mess of a communication error and I'm still iffy on whether I have that good of a reason to assume anyone's mafia status or lack thereof.

[banter]

As an aside, thank you for sparing me, Supaaku. Yeah, I just got a bit confused what with double-posting and all, but I'll make sure not to do it again.

[Supaaku]

And to answer the question about Grey Fox. They must kill someone at night. So either they have chosen the same person as Naomi, chosen a person with Stealth Camo or were tortured by Ocelot.

Also to clarify the Don't post PMs rule, that was mainly just for the first one I sent out telling you your role. Any information you get from me during the nights you're free to use or share with others as you like. Just don't post screencaps or anything.

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch

Kitsune Dzelda: Lynch Banter
Granny Benson: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda
Alec: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda
Banter: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda
E-Goat: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda
Chopstix: Lynch Granny Benson
Guyperson: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda
FlyingGiraffe: Lynch Granny Benson
Need Runes4: Lynch Kitsune Dzelda

[Cori]

I'm going to wait on voting for now because I am way too tired to think straight. I had an all-nighter trying to finish a project for 3d design and THEN I had to take a test in history.

When I'm feeling a bit less crummy I'll re-read the thread and maybe make a decision then.

[Kitsune Dzelda]

My explanation is that I almost always take the offensive on assaults. All the time. Regardless of side. XD I like to point things out I see, often without regard of health. Its a shame you dont know me, but thats how I work. I know Ill go out rather quickly now that Ive become a target, Im not particularly bothered about it; but just what will happen from my death? You people will have alot more to go on in your investigations.

However, I know that Im innocent. So how will I exactly react when someone says Im suspicious? Suspect them immediately. Thats why youve got my eye on you Banter. I really am not this good at the game, despite watching several games. I think I was mostly looking forward to the giant robots.

And when I say new people die quickly, I meant me. Not Banter. Sorry I didnt make that clearer before. That said though, I know Im innocent, despite the contrary behavior. :3

[The Nightman]

Why does Banter have your eye on him? That sounds frightening.

[Kitsune Dzelda]

Because, he didnt listen about the poisoned linguine. I told him that stuff was in the fridge for too long, but would he listen noooooooooo.

Thats what happens to coworkers that steal bag lunches repeatedly.

[banter]

I believe I've made my case the best I can, although anyone who wants me to clarify something about my motives can feel free to ask. I suspected Dzelda because suspecting someone seemed like a better choice than random lynching or not lynching anyone. Didn't want to give the mafia a free shot at us for another day or to just lash out and lynch someone I had no reason to suspect.

My lead on Dzelda was a weak one. That much I'll admit. I'm still not sure she's not a townsperson; she could still be Solid goddamn Snake for all I know. Do we have any other leads? Not really, no. So at this point, I'm gonna suggest we lynch Kitsune Dzelda. You may know you're innocent, but wouldn't we all say that about ourselves?