Mint Marshmallow Mix Mafia POSTGAME - TOWN WINS!

[Kamak]

Most conclusive evidence we have yet. Sorry Pooh Bear.

Lynch Neffy

[Nefarious Bear]

Okay before I die, let me leave you with some "info"

Darkin is mafia.

Zenith is mafia.

Galaxy Man is totally innocent.

Angelic is innocent too.

The rest you'll have to figure out yourselves. Don't wanna ruin all the people's fun.

Am I messing with your heads? Are the mafia really mafia? Or they really are mafia but you think I'm framing them so you'll think they'll innocent? Am I trying to waste the cop's time?

It all depends on how you wanna interpret my information and/or role.

[Kamak]

There's no way the mafia can hide you being a cop, and if you're mafia, you wouldn't out your comrades unless you were going to ragequit over being lynched, which I don't think is happening.

If you are mafia, I can see you trying to finger innocents and protect your cohorts by saying they're guilty or innocent respectively, but even then, it seems a bit too obvious.

I'd just ignore what Neffy says, unless the second cop wants to investigate further.

However, I don't think Cori is going to live through the night, if they are in fact the original cop.

[Nefarious Bear]

I may not be outing my mafia members. I may be trying to protect them. You never know what I'm trying to do. It could be straight up info, or me trying to invoke reverse psychology. You wont know unless you investigate.

[Kamak]

It's okay Neffy.

We all know that you're Kira.

Just don't make me shoot you.

[Nefarious Bear]

[Flicky]

Nefarious Bear, Goon, Mafia-sided was tossed down a well.

NIGHT SIX

[Nefarious Bear]

[Flicky]

Darkin, Townie, Town-sided was found dead in a dumpster.

Coriserai, Cop, Town-sided didn't fare much better, and her tattered remains were found outside of the garbage disposal.

DAY SIX

[Cori]

I...I did my duty....*hrrk*

AVENGE MEEEEeeeeeeee.........




(don't ask me how a bloody pile of corpse meat is still capable of speech
I AM A GHOST
FEAR ME)

[Madican]

We'll make this a ghost town.

[AngelicSongx]

It's hard to believe that there's 10 of us left.

[Zorinth]

Well, 1 or 2 mafia left(traitor found or not) and 1 cop, also one person who might have gotten an investigation off(skitzo crazy killer)
1 miller as well, so to the cop that's alive, unless you think you are gonna get killed tonight or have 2-3 people found guilty that are alive don't say anything till you do find more.
Also to the Skitzo WHAT HAVE YOU DONE, YOU INSANE BEAST, YOU KILLED DARKIN, but really im surprised this is the first townie skitzo death(i think).
On to Bears thing before he died, what bad luck having darkin, one of the people you called mafia, well I didn't trust him in the first place, I would say don't worry about anything he said, I bet everyone mentioned was innocent, though it just may be worth looking into if you feel you have the time.

[Noffletoff]

Alright, I will reveal myself so that we can actually get something done before the mafia really does start to kill us off.

There's 10 people left, 7 or 8 are townies, 2 or 3 are anti town.

It would take the mafia 7 days ot 8 days to kill the town (Unless the skitzo wants to kill off townies, that's koo), and I have narrowed it down to 5 suspects.

I'm the FBI agent.

First, my investigations are as followed.

Night 1 : Betrippin is not the Cannibal!

Night 2: Sol Reaper is innocent! (Hah, god father)

Night 3: Lotharu is guilty! (Miller :<)

Night 4: Bacon is innocent.

Night 5: Dragoon is innocent.

Night 6: ZenithOfChaos is Innocent.

Now for Coriserais investigations.

I thought this would happen. Sorry, Nef, but I had a feeling you'd try to pick me off when I voted to lynch you yesterday.

I am the Cop.

Here are the results of my five investigations:
Night one
Bacon--Innocent

Night two
ShadowGuy--Innocent

Night three
Dragoon--Innocent

Night four
Nefarious Bear--Guilty

Night five
Noffletoff--Innocent

Now if we take the list of players in the game, we can start to determain who is innocent and who is guilty

1. Kamak
2. Noffletoff - FBI Agent (Me)
3. Galaxy Man
4. D-vid - Goon, Deceased
5. ZenithOfChaos - Innocent
6. AngelicSongx
7. Dragoon - Innocent
8. Bacon - Innocent
9. Nefarious Bear - Goon, Lynched
10. Coriserai - Cop, Deceased
11. Zorinth
12. Madican - Thief, Deceased
13. Darkin - Townie, Deceased
14. Supaaku - Bomb, Deceased
15. Somepartsareme - Townie, Deceased
16. Potato
17. Gryewolf - Cannibal, Deceased
18. ShadowGuy - Innocent
19. Lotharu - Miller, Deceased
20. betrippin - Townie, Smitten
21. Chopstix - Mafia Goon, Deceased
22. FatOldRobot - Watcher, Deceased
23. Sol Reaper - Godfather, Deceased
24. Guyperson - Townie, Lynched

This leaves us with 5 people who could be mafia / the traitor.

Kamak, Galaxy Man, AngelicsongX, Zorinth and Potato.

Now how do we determain who of these is mafia? I went through old records to see what I could find.

First, Kamak

And guys, keep in mind, if we don't lynch, we're guaranteed to not hit a townie or a cop and we give the cops an extra day to weed out more scum.

Let the mafia pick off townies, random lynching at this point is shooting in the water with no real evidence. At best we can get lucky and pick one off, but otherwise, we're likely going to thin ourselves out and make it more likely that the mafia are going to find our cops.

Yeah, no lynch seems boring, but let's wait for the cops to come out with their findings so we got a better chance of winning this thing.

I'm voting No Lynch until someone has enough good reasoning to convince me to vote otherwise.

Kamak seems to have been understanding about how townies had a big advantage, which leads me to think he isn't really mafia,

Most conclusive evidence we have yet. Sorry Pooh Bear.

Lynch Neffy

He also vote to lynch Neffy, which could mean that he is really innocent, or he knows that neffy was the miller and voted to kill a towny, although it wouldn't have helped the mafia to kill the miller.

Now for Galaxy Man

You do seem pretty jumpy, Neffy.

you do seem really really nervous and it's sort of suspicious dude

Neffy was pretty pushy when it cames to lynching and overall going against the flow, it makes me wonder if he was the traitor, and the mafia found out and recruited him, making him a goon.

Galaxy Man hasn't said much in the game to really make him suspicious.

Third, Zorinth

woops,
well to say for sure now Lynch Bear

Zorinth also voted to lynch Bear, which means he is either innocent, or knew that he was just a miller.

There wasn't much to bring up against him, other than he was randomly trying to get lynchs.

Potato

Potato hasn't said anything in the last two days, I can't say anything about him.

Angelicsongx

She has been pro town the whole game, I don't know if it's just a cover, or if she's really innocent.

Honestly this whole paragraph of vomit I just spewed probably didn't help with anything, but we do know now that there are only 5 suspects, 2 or 3 could be anti town.

There's the traitor (Could have been neffy converted)
There's a possible miller
There's a hooker
There's a Possible Goon

There's now a good chance that lynching one of these 5 will result in a mafia kill.

[ShadowGuy]

10 people alive in total. 8 town, 1 mafia and a possible 2nd, if not 1 3rd party. If the mafia haven't/can't recruit the traitor, then we only need to get rid of the hooker. The traitor cannot win unless the mafia win, and the mafia cannot win with no members. So there is a 1/5 chance to hit mafia/3rd party, 4/5 to hit town. We could then compress the list of innocent people from Coriserai, which was confirmed as the cop from dying, and remove Bacon, Dragoon, Noffletoff and ShadowGuy (Me) from lynching. So that leaves 6 people to choose from overall, 2 mafia or 1 mafia and 1 traitor to hit, only requiring to hit the mafia. We could get a list from the other cop and Skitzo to shorten the list even more.

We could wait one more day, making 7 town, 1 mafia and a possible 2nd, if not third party Traitor so the cop can confirm another person from the other unconfirmed town and themself, shortening the list by atlease 1 (since the other cop may already be confirmed by Coriserai). That will leave 5 or less people to choose from, which may be the same odds as random lynching if the previous day. Won't work if Cop is random killed by mafia.

My opinion goes towards the first option, which the cop can admit to being the cop and provide a list if people start lynching him/her, meaning they will become targeted by mafia at night but leaves less possible people to choose from the list of possible suspects. The cop should admit to being cop now in my opinion if they know atlease 1 other innocent person that is not confirmed, thus shortening the possible mafia list.

If the Skitzo only picks people from the possible victims list, and if town continuously picks people of from the list of possible people along with mafia killing people (which would more than likely be killing people from the confirmed innocent list), then tomorrow will have 3 confirmed, if cop or Skitzo doesn't effect (which they will can't if they target people o the possible mafia list and not waisting time in the confirmed), 6 town in total and 1/2 mafia and/or 1 traitor, if we don't hit any. Then cop (and the Skitzo may aswell) would have more information if not killed, shortening the possible people list. If not, 5 possible peoe in the mafia list. The next day, 2 confirmed left if cop/Skitzo haven't died/did nothing helpful, 4 town in total with 1/2 mafia and/or 1 traitor if we still have not hit any of them, which is unlikely. 4 people in the possible mafia list. That is if Skitzo doesn't kill anyone, which if he/she does help shorten the list and if he/she investigates, and the cop doesn't reveal any new information/the cop is dead.

The possible list of Mafia being unconfirmed as innocent are as follows: Galaxy, Kamak, AngelicSongX, Potato and Zorinth.

And I was just Ninja'd by Noffletoff and he was the cop, decreasing all the possible mafia people by 1 in each example. Awesome. 5 to choose from now.


Opinions, and if we do so, who do we choose?