Ye olde Mafia, what the hell is even going on THE END

[Dragoon]

But you're very good at this game, and so you could be faking that you're on the side of the mafia.

[Nefarious Bear]

Maybe, but the nature of this game means you cant know for sure.

[Dragoon]

Exactly, so a random guess isn't completely off, which is why my vote is to lynch you.

[Nefarious Bear]

Not entirely sure how I can defend myself from "You're too much of threat, no matter what side you're on, so we're going to lynch you". So I guess I'll wait for the others to respond.

[saximaphone]

I think we have reached an impasse.

[Sol Reaper]

"You're too much of threat, no matter what side you're on, so we're going to lynch you"

I think that's why Exeres quit playing Mafia on this board.

[electronic goat]

Oh my. Honestly, things are just getting worse. I have a nagging feeling that I can't trust Flicky still.
And I don't know how to respond to all of this. Flicky is still suspicious to me, I can't see any real reason to lynch Neffy, but it's coming down to the time where I'll have to settle to Launch Nefarious Bear.

Also, since I suggested typewith.me and it turned out to be a piece of shit, I guess I am responsible for stalling the mafia. Hooray.

[Noffletoff]

I'm just a simple villager

He seems legit.

I'm going to change mine to undecided, because I don't know what I'm doing.

[Nefarious Bear]

The "Nefarious" joke is getting old. Nonetheless we need to see some more votes.

[Nefarious Bear]

Oh my. Honestly, things are just getting worse. I have a nagging feeling that I can't trust Flicky still.
And I don't know how to respond to all of this. Flicky is still suspicious to me, I can't see any real reason to lynch Neffy, but it's coming down to the time where I'll have to settle to Launch Nefarious Bear.

Also, since I suggested typewith.me and it turned out to be a piece of shit, I guess I am responsible for stalling the mafia. Hooray.

Bandwagoning isn't exactly the best way to choose a victim to lynch.

[electronic goat]

Oh my. Honestly, things are just getting worse. I have a nagging feeling that I can't trust Flicky still.
And I don't know how to respond to all of this. Flicky is still suspicious to me, I can't see any real reason to lynch Neffy, but it's coming down to the time where I'll have to settle to Launch Nefarious Bear.

Also, since I suggested typewith.me and it turned out to be a piece of shit, I guess I am responsible for stalling the mafia. Hooray.

Bandwagoning isn't exactly the best way to choose a victim to lynch.

It's the only way to choose a victim to lynch, unless you get a gun.

[saximaphone]

C'mooooon...

One of you must want to die, right?

[Nefarious Bear]

You should lynch based on reasoning rather than bandwagoning.

[Supaaku]

Basically, my reasoning boils down to using you as bait. If you're mafia, other mafia will usually try to defend you. If you're town, that puts G-Man at the top of my suspicion list. And thus the process repeats itself until we start hitting mafia power roles. There is the possibility that the mafia will go quiet and try to avoid drawing attention to themselves as a result of this tactic, though I would think it would actually draw more attention for an active member to go silent.

Mafia lost the last game because the power roles got taken out pretty much straight away. I want to do the same thing to the mafia in this game.

[Kamak]

You should lynch based on reasoning rather than bandwagoning.

At this point, it has to be between you and Flicky, for the simple fact that if neither of you is the sheriff, then the sheriff needs to investigate one of you to see which is scum.

If we lynch flicky and he is innocent, we might lose our Sheriff or the Naive Sheriff (which means the Sheriff is vulnerable). If he's spared, the Mafia might take care of him, which means they have to waste a night kill to get rid of him. If he's scum, well, the real sheriff can tell us about that tomorrow.

You, on the other hand, are only a villager if you are innocent. It'll suck to lose you, but we wouldn't be losing our last chance to hunt out mafia outside of random lynching. If you are guilty though, we will be one step closer to beating the town.

Also, keep in mind, if you are scum, your votes will be very telling to us. You want to get rid of Flicky. If you're revealed to be scum, it's very likely that he is innocent and telling the truth.

Right now, you're the safer choice in who to kill. We could drag a third person into this, but we only have one sheriff, which again, could very well be Flicky.

So I vote to lynch Neffy. I hope I'm making the right decision.