AWKWARD ZOMBIE

SaintCrazy wrote:Wait a minute, so the mafia killed Tales (because otherwise he would have shown up as mafia), right?

That's not how that works. The Mafia WANTS the Miller alive. As long as the Miller is alive, he's added protection. If the Mafia knows who the Miller is, then implicating him as a killer then letting him get lynched gives off the idea that a Mafia member is dead, which would lead to confusion if/when it becomes clear that there are suddenly more mafia then there should be.

The Clockmaker is the only one who could have done it. Especially since, as a miller, Tales had no night actions and thought he was Vanilla Villager. He couldn't have visited the Granny in order to be killed by her.

This is, of course, assuming that the Clockmaker did it. Which, of course, there's a 50/50 chance there. Madican could have been the one killed. The same rules Tales had applies to him as well, he can't go anywhere at night.

It dosen't exactly MATTER who did which, though. Just clarifying the point that the Granny couldn't have done anything, and the Mafia wants Millers alive.

I feel like there are too many roles in this game. Yes, there's a lot of people but all these roles just confuse people.

And yeah confusion and not knowing are the point of this game, but not via complication.

i guess because its supposed to technically "round whatever; advanced hardmode"

Yeah, but the mafia probably didn't know Tales was a miller after only one night.

Still, the big question is, will we lynch anyone today? We don't have a lot of information but at the same time I feel like the stakes are higher than in the previous games, since more than one person can die at night now.

I'd vote a tentative no lynch for now, though.

SaintCrazy wrote:Wait a minute, so the mafia killed Tales (because otherwise he would have shown up as mafia), right?

So the clockmaker must've killed Madican.

Unless I'm totally wrong and I missed some other role that can kill people. It wouldn't have been the Granny, because Madican would've had to have a night action to visit her.

The millers only show as mafia if they are lynched.

gotcha chief

I also think that there's not enough info to really make an informed lynch, but at the same time, there's so many killing roles that not lynching is almost as dangerous as lynching.

I wouldn't vote for a lynching, either.

yeah i vote no lynch

i mean on one hand i feel like the stakes are high, as Saint said, but we have bodaciously nothing to go on

maybe tomorrow something will come up?

the mafia sure like killing me

Ugh, I wrote up so much only to be ninja'd twice.
Screw it, no-lynch is my vote. I doubt we could convince enough people to lynch anybody yet, anyway.

My last post was a no lynch vote, by the way.

Yeah no-lynch sounds awright. If we had more info that's be great but unfortunately the first night is like that.

No lynch for me, just to confirm.

We will definitely need to be watching everyone and gathering evidence for tomorrow, though.

Also gona have to Vote No Lynch

not enough evidence yet.