The Legend of Zelda

[Winchester]

First Zelda I ever saw was one of the NES titles (I don't remember which), first one I played was OoT, and first I owned and completed was Wind Waker.

I think Wind Waker will always be my favorite

[Galaxy Man]

Wind Waker was so by far the best Zelda game, even with it's one stupid giant fetch quest of pain.

[DoNotDelete]

I think Wind Waker is one of my least favourite Zeldas, but I can't say I ever really liked Majora's Mask either.

I haven't finished Skyward Sword but I can't say it really caught my imagination.

I personally like Twilight Princess more than the above games - but I probably enjoyed Link's Awakening the most.

[cody]

Wind Waker was so by far the best Zelda game, even with it's one stupid giant fetch quest of pain.

Wow, five of us putting Wind Waker first. Hamazing.

I liked Skyward Sword except for the sword mechanic. Motion controls are something that have never grown on me in any context whatsoever. I particularly enjoyed how much Link looked like Taylor Swift.

[CommanderPepper]

Wind Waker is my favorite Zelda but, the best Zelda game has to be either Majora's Mask or LttP.

[Cori]

Minish Cap and Twilight Princess are my favorite Zelda games because they were my gateway to the series. I don't think any one Zelda game is the 'best' Zelda game of all time, but I still have my preferences.

[Madican]

Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess are my favorites. I just couldn't finish Wind Waker after finding out about the mandatory massive fetch quest. I said nope and dumped the game.

[Kitsune Dzelda]

Hey your loss, my gain. I found a Wind Waker Gamecube copy in a used bin at a Movie Gallery (shame theyre closed, I miss their manager)

Good as new, and even better to play

[Kamak]

Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess are my favorites. I just couldn't finish Wind Waker after finding out about the mandatory massive fetch quest. I said nope and dumped the game.

The fetch quest, I think, is overhyped for how bad it is. Really, getting the maps themselves were one of the best parts because I found the last two dungeons a bit lacking, and the maps were located in basically mini-dungeons. I mean, the ghost ship itself was freaking cool. I didn't have to worry about gathering Rupees because I got the wallets as soon as I was given freedom in the Great Sea, and even going out and pulling them from the bottom of the ocean wasn't bad considering I had already gotten the rest of the treasure from the regular treasure maps.

I will say it wasn't my favorite part of the game at times (fucking Redeads), but I really felt iffy about the second half of Wind Waker when I had 2 escort dungeons back to back and the only redeeming thing about them was the bosses.

[Crawfish]

First Game Played: Legend of Zelda NES (found it at a garage sale, so cash)

First Game Beaten: Oracle of Ages

Favorite Game: Wind Waker

For some reason, Wind Waker is perfect. On paper, it shouldn't be, because it is guilty of some things I hate about modern Zelda: not enough dungeons, fetch quests, not very creative items, etc. But for some reason, the story, art style, and characters won me over. I think it's just because it ties the whole mythology of the series together, and is easily the most "movie-like" of any Zelda. The way it tells the story is just perfect and captivating.

While we're talking about ALttP: I like it a lot and have beaten it twice, but compared to modern Zelda it's boring and lacking. I also wish there could have been more variety in the musical scores. If they ever re-make it with like, a complete overhaul, it would be an amazing game.

(don't get me started on Twilight Princess being anyone's favorite, we all know what will come of that)

[Syobon]

The treasure hunt in WW isn't that bad if you liked the sailing. And I loved the sailing.

[Kitsune Dzelda]

Screw you I loved Twilight princess because of Mr. Dude-On -A-Boar.

Dont care if you tell me "Ohhh his name is King Bulbin!" No hes NOT:

Hes Mr. Dude-On-A-Boar, and I am having so much fun blowing him up with bomb arrows as he tries to smash me with a tree he picked up and carried off earlier XD

[Ariever]

Yea, TP was the only reason I got hooked on zelda. I will play any game wit h a wolf in it.



ANY GAME.

[Crawfish]

Good arguments for TP's favor

[Ariever]

I first saw the trailer of TP and I thought,"Link turns into a wolf? Ok, I MUST have this game!" I finished it that week when I got it with the help of Zenda Dungeon for the city in the sky.