Chocolate Mafia - DAY 1

[Lotharu]

I vote Retardus

[Brekkjern]

Not lynching anyone gives us no information guys. And they still get to kill one of us during the night :S

If we lynch the cop or the doctor accidentally , we're pretty screwed though. I usually wait one extra night so you can cross-reference who voted who with who got killed. But I have to say Ycobb is looking pretty suspicious, but I'm biased of course :p.

Killing the cop or doctor would be unfortunate. I agree. No real way of knowing who is who though, so jumping into it might be a decent idea.

[Syobon]

Looks like someone will get lynched anyway so yeah.

[YCobb]

Not lynching anyone gives us no information guys. And they still get to kill one of us during the night :S

If we lynch the cop or the doctor accidentally , we're pretty screwed though. I usually wait one extra night so you can cross-reference who voted who with who got killed. But I have to say Ycobb is looking pretty suspicious, but I'm biased of course :p.

Killing the cop or doctor would be unfortunate. I agree. No real way of knowing who is who though, so jumping into it might be a decent idea.

No, Syo was right (but probably trying to mislead us in some other way!!!), we (please note that I am using this word but excluding that traitor Syobon from its span)can look at votes and check for some patterns, at least.

[saximaphone]

I kind of liked Syobon's original plan of waiting.
We can't risk putting 2 of our most important people on the chopping block.
But since it looks like we'll lynch anyways, I'll take a shot in the dark.
I vote Ami no Akai.

And if Snarf was the Fool, does that mean he wins?

[Brekkjern]

The fool has to be lynched to win. He got killed by the mafia so... No. He does not win.

[Crawfish]

I vote for SaintCrazy because that sounds like a prime mafia name

[Chopstix]

I am nominating Chopstix for death.

Haha, someone doesn't know how to play mafia.

You never lynch day one unless you have a cop that found scum. So, this witchhunt will end up screwing over the village if they lynhc with no information. Unless the cop has a guilty. So, any cop wanna claim with a guilty? Or should we no lynch and then get the cop to claim next turn if he has a guilty? I'd rather no lynch and get more evidence.

[saximaphone]

^This.^

Makes sense.

I change to no lynch.

[Lordy]

That's a good point, actually.

I change to no lynch.

[Brekkjern]

Following the trend then... No lynch.

[Lotharu]

I think the cop should check someone out, too, so changing to no lynch sounds good.

[saximaphone]

THEN IT IS AGREED!

[ShadowGuy]

Saximaphone, you seem to have agreed the whole time to not voting anybody, as if you were afraid of getting out or wanted to aid the mafia in getting another free kill. Why? Saying it is better seems odd, as you have been the first to agree to Chopstix and pointed out you liked Syobon's idea of it. You also seemed like you wanted to get everyone to agree with not voting anyone with that post saying "THEN IT IS AGREED!"

The next part is: Is Chopstix and/or Syobon apart of it, or are they serious on wasting time to hope that the cop will find one mafia? 10 +1 Cop +1 Doctor to 1 mafia boss +4 mafia grunts (or whatever you want to call them). The cop has a 5 in 11 (The cop himself) chance to find one of 5 potential threats and it decreases as a mafia member is caught.

Also Chopstix, pointing fingers is a smart move as you get to see people's reactions, as you would know since you were insulting Brekkjern on not knowing how to play.

Changed to Saximaphone, as that seems most likely, while Chopstix could be fishing for responses and has nothing to fear due to being 1 of the 10 innocent people, not a cop or doctor since it would be too risky. Still, I'm keeping an eye on Chopstix.

You are all welcome to disagree with this, but I would like reasoning to why.

[Lordy]

...Shadow, I now deem your avatar accurate.

And I'm leaving for a week in around ten minutes, so if the game lasts that long I will return

(if I haven't been lynched in my sleep)